Alright, folks, let’s cut through the noise and get to the meat of this “Trackergate” mess. Washoe County District Judge David Hardy just dropped a bombshell on June 17, 2025, ruling that John Doe, the guy who dared to poke around the shady dealings of Reno Mayor Hillary Schieve and former Washoe County Commissioner Vaughn Hartung, gets to keep his name under wraps for now. And let me tell you, Hardy’s call wasn’t just right, it’s a lifeline for every American who believes in holding the powerful accountable without getting their life torched. But the fight’s not over. This case is now knocking on the U.S. Supreme Court’s door, and the justices have a chance to either cement free speech or let petty tyrants like Schieve and Hartung turn Nevada into a dystopian snitch state. Buckle up, because this one’s a wild ride.
First, let’s debunk the garbage spewed by the Reno Gazette Journal. They claim Doe “paid a private investigator to spy” on Schieve and Hartung. Wrong. Doe didn’t hire anyone to “spy.” He hired a licensed private investigator, David McNeely, to dig into serious allegations, dozens of them, mind you, against these two public servants. We’re talking claims that could land people in prison or bar them from office forever, with whispers of shady business owners, developers, and even casinos tangled in the mess. Doe, being a responsible citizen, didn’t just fling these accusations onto YouTube like some unhinged TikToker. He followed the law, hired a pro, and said, “Check this out.” That’s not spying, that’s due diligence. The RGJ’s lazy smear is journalistic malpractice, and they should be ashamed.
Here’s the kicker: McNeely didn’t even do the job properly. The guy was sick, his words, not mine, and admitted he never followed through on investigating the claims. No tracking, no tailing, no nothing. Doe never told him to slap GPS trackers on anyone’s cars, and McNeely himself said Doe gave him zero instructions on how to run the investigation. Those trackers? McNeely’s solo act, and guess what? They were 100% legal when he used them, before Nevada’s Assembly Bill 356 kicked in on July 1, 2023. So, the RGJ’s narrative that Doe orchestrated some creepy surveillance op is pure fiction. They’re not reporting, they’re auditioning for a Netflix conspiracy thriller.
Now, let’s talk about Doe’s real mistake, not breaking the law, because he didn’t, but thinking he could trust the system to handle this quietly. He should’ve just dumped all the evidence, witness statements, allegations, the whole shebang, on YouTube and let the internet do its thing. Imagine the chaos: millions of views, X blowing up, and Schieve and Hartung sweating bullets as the world decides if they belong in jail or exile. Instead, Doe played by the rules, hired a licensed PI, and now he’s fighting for his life at the Supreme Court to keep his name secret. Why? Because Schieve, Hartung, and their press lapdogs are out for blood, desperate to paint him as a villain when he’s just a guy who wanted the truth.
The allegations against Schieve and Hartung aren’t small potatoes. Sources say they range from life-in-prison-level crimes to stuff that’d make them radioactive in public office. We’re talking corruption, backroom deals, maybe even worse, with a web of influential players allegedly involved. Doe didn’t want to torch reputations without proof, so he hired McNeely to verify the claims. Too bad McNeely was too ill to deliver. But the fact that dozens of people came forward with these accusations should have Schieve and Hartung quaking, not suing. If this case goes to trial, discovery could unleash a flood of witnesses and evidence that’ll make their “privacy” whining look like a bad joke. Pass the popcorn.
Judge Hardy’s ruling is a masterstroke. He gets it: outing Doe while his appeal’s pending would gut his constitutional protections. “There is an important public policy at issue,” Hardy wrote, and he’s spot-on. The First Amendment isn’t just for loudmouths on X, it’s for citizens like Doe who dig for truth without wanting to be martyred. Hardy’s refusal to let Schieve and Hartung’s legal tantrum steamroll Doe’s rights is the kind of judicial courage we need more of. The man deserves a standing ovation for standing up to this political hit job.
The U.S. Supreme Court now holds the keys. Doe’s petition asks whether investigations tied to free speech are protected, not just the speech itself. It’s a no-brainer: if you can’t investigate corruption without fear of being doxxed, free speech is dead. Schieve and Hartung’s attorney, Adam Hosmer-Henner, filed a waiver on June 16, shrugging off Doe’s petition like it’s frivolous. Arrogant move, but it shows they’re scared. They know if the court takes this case, their victim act could crumble. The justices should hear this, rule for Doe, and send a message: public officials don’t get to weaponize courts to silence critics.
If the Supreme Court sides with Doe, it’s game over for Schieve and Hartung’s vendetta. If they don’t, and Doe’s unmasked, watch out. A guy with nothing to lose might just spill everything, every allegation, every witness, every dirty secret, onto the internet. Schieve and Hartung should be terrified of that day, because the truth doesn’t play favorites. The press, too, should rethink their role as cheerleaders for power. Smearing Doe won’t bury the story, it’ll only make it louder.
In the end, Hardy did the right thing, and the Supreme Court has a chance to follow suit. Protect Doe, protect free speech, and remind public servants they’re not above scrutiny. Anything less, and we’re one step closer to a world where asking questions gets you crushed. Let’s hope the justices see the stakes and deliver justice, because if they don’t, the fireworks are just getting started, and Schieve and Hartung might not like the show.
————————————————————————————
Speak Up, Nevada! What’s on Your Mind? Send us your opinion!
Got the inside scoop on something happening in Nevada? Or the country? Do you have thoughts about life in Nevada that are too good to keep to yourself? Whether it’s a hot take on our politics, crime, education, or even the secret to surviving our summers, we’re all ears! Swing them our way at editor@thenevadaglobe.com. Come on, give us the scoop on what makes Nevada tick—or what ticks you off. Let’s make some noise and have some fun with it!