Here’s the deal: a private investigator, David McNeely, did his job. He tracked Reno Mayor Hillary Schieve and former Washoe County Commissioner Vaughn Hartung using GPS devices. Was it sneaky? Sure. Was it illegal? Not even close. At the time, Nevada had no law banning such tactics, none, zip, nada. They had to scramble to pass Assembly Bill 356 after the fact, effective July 1, 2023, just to make it a crime. That’s right, McNeely operated in a legal free zone, and his client, the mysterious John Doe, didn’t even ask for the tracking. Doe just wanted dirt on alleged corruption, not a Google Maps play-by-play. This whole fiasco reeks of political vengeance, not justice, and yet here we are with an oral argument scheduled for April 8, 2025, at 10:00 AM PDT, at the Nevada Supreme Court in Carson City.

Let’s start with the Sparks Police Department. They botched this from the jump. Instead of treating Schieve like any other citizen, say, you or me finding a tracker on our car, they rolled out the red carpet. They handed her McNeely’s name on a silver platter, no criminal charges in sight, and whispered, “Go get a lawyer.” Why? Because she’s the mayor. If this was Joe Schmo from Sparks, they’d have shrugged and said, “Not our problem.” Instead, they torched McNeely’s life, his business, his reputation, over something that wasn’t even a crime. Special treatment much? The Sparks PD should’ve stayed in their lane, not played errand boys for a politician’s vendetta.

Now, imagine John Doe’s identity gets spilled. Picture this: you’re a concerned citizen in Las Vegas, suspicious your city councilman’s taking kickbacks. You hire a PI to poke around, legally, mind you. Next thing you know, your name’s plastered across the Review-Journal, X lights up with pitchforks, and the government’s auditing your taxes. Judas Priest, the implications are terrifying!

Everyday folks could get hauled into court for snapping a photo of a council meeting, digging through public records, or even asking too many questions at a town hall, all because some judge decided your “anonymity” isn’t worth squat. Your life’s ruined, your boss fires you, and the press paints you as a stalker. That’s the precedent here. Expose John Doe, and you’ve just handed every petty tyrant a playbook to crush dissent.

And who’s bankrolling Schieve and Hartung’s legal crusade? That’s the million-dollar question. Is this is a campaign contribution in disguise, say, from big donors, or even the law firm attacking David and Doe? We deserve to know! Transparency’s their buzzword when it suits them, so let’s see the receipts. Funny how Schieve’s attorney, Adam Hosmer-Henner, tossed $500 to The Nevada Independent, cozy with her pals like Jessica Sferrazza and Devon Reese. Smells like a quid pro quo to me.

Then there’s Washoe County Judge David Hardy. Conflict of interest? Seems so! He’s entrenched in the local legal scene, presiding over a case involving elected officials he’s likely rubbed elbows with at county shindigs. His rulings, like forcing McNeely to name his client, scream bias. He should’ve recused himself faster than you can say “small-town politics.” Letting him steer this ship is like letting the fox guard the henhouse.

If this case stumbles forward, it might just backfire spectacularly. What if John Doe’s allegations, corruption, malfeasance, hold water? Discovery could unearth witnesses, emails, maybe even a smoking gun. Schieve and Hartung might strut into court thinking they’re the victims, only to limp out with their reputations in tatters. Imagine the headlines: “Reno Mayor’s Dirty Laundry Aired in Court.” They’d be pariahs, pointed at in every diner from Reno to Carson City. This isn’t about privacy, it’s about power, and they’re betting the farm they can bluff their way through.

Here’s the kicker: no laws were broken. McNeely’s actions were kosher when he did them, and John Doe never greenlit the tracking, just the investigation. Doe broke zero laws. This is political theater, pure and simple, a circus to punish a citizen for daring to question the throne. If it proceeds, my money’s on an implosion that’ll make Schieve and Hartung wish they’d never poked this hornet’s nest. The truth has a funny way of biting back. We wonder if our new U.S. Attorney for Nevada will be looking into this soon as well. Stay tuned, this political theater is popcorn-worthy for sure!

Speak Up, Nevada! What’s on Your Mind? Send us your opinion!

Got the inside scoop on something happening in Nevada? Or the country? Do you have thoughts about life in Nevada that are too good to keep to yourself? Whether it’s a hot take on our politics, crime, education, or even the secret to surviving our summers, we’re all ears! Swing them our way at editor@thenevadaglobe.com. Come on, give us the scoop on what makes Nevada tick—or what ticks you off. Let’s make some noise and have some fun with it!